In today’s dynamic and rapidly changing business environment, uncertainty has become a constant factor that managers must learn to navigate. Scientific research and the experiences of leading business organizations provide valuable insights into effective decision-making under uncertainty.
The Nature of Uncertainty in Decision-Making
Uncertainty is a multidimensional phenomenon that fundamentally affects decision-making processes. Scientific research provides increasing evidence of different types of uncertainty and their impact on decision-making. According to researchers from Harvard Business Review, traditional analytical tools—such as market research, value chain analysis, or competitive assessments—work well in stable business environments but can be dangerous when faced with unprecedented uncertainty. Applying old tools in new conditions may lead to strategies that neither protect the company from threats nor take advantage of the opportunities that uncertainty can create.
Scientists distinguish several levels of uncertainty that require different decision-making approaches. At the lowest level, referred to as a “reasonably clear future,” managers can develop a single forecast that is sufficiently precise for strategic planning. However, in many contemporary business situations, higher levels of uncertainty make future outcomes harder to predict.
Researchers also differentiate between three types of uncertainty: expected uncertainty, unexpected uncertainty, and volatility. Particularly interesting is unexpected uncertainty, which results from fundamental changes in learned predictive relationships and signals the need to revise assumptions about the best course of action. This type of uncertainty requires a mechanism to suppress potentially outdated expectations and encourage faster adaptation to new conditions.
The Impact of Uncertainty on Organizations and Individuals
Uncertainty significantly affects both organizations and individuals in the workplace. A study conducted by HSBC found that nearly half (48%) of respondents had experienced increased stress and anxiety in the past five years, and more than half (52%) expected these pressures to rise in the coming years. Moreover, 53% of respondents reported a lack of confidence in their decision-making.
Uncertainty can lead to “decision paralysis,” where the inability to predict outcomes results in hesitation. Around 26% of respondents reported experiencing this paralysis when faced with complex decisions, often due to fear of making the wrong choice. This is particularly evident in finance, where decisions can have wide-ranging impacts on company strategy, client relationships, and financial portfolios.
From a psychological perspective, uncertainty is an aversive and stressful experience that is positively correlated with anxiety, governed by the behavioral inhibition system (BIS). BIS controls responses to conflicting, ambiguous, or novel stimuli and is responsible for the anxiety experienced in uncertain situations. Coping with uncertainty consumes self-regulation resources, and when uncertainty is induced, people tend to choose easier and less demanding options compared to when they feel confident.
Decision-Making Strategies Under Uncertainty
Both research and business practices provide a range of strategies to aid decision-making in uncertain environments. According to Gartner, effective decision-making under increasing complexity and uncertainty should be more connected, contextual, and continuous.
– **Connected decision-making** means that no decision exists in isolation. Decisions made by one actor influence others within the company and its ecosystem, and vice versa. Sharing data and insights across organizational boundaries is crucial.
– **Contextual decision-making** implies that decision alternatives must be assessed in a broader context beyond a single event or transaction. Organizations often neglect giving their business data and analytics the same level of personalization that they expect as consumers.
Research from MIT Sloan Management Review suggests that companies that strengthen their learning capabilities with artificial intelligence are significantly better prepared to handle uncertainty caused by technological, regulatory, and talent disruptions compared to firms with limited learning capabilities. A notable example is **Estée Lauder Companies**, which leverages AI to detect and respond quickly to consumer trends, helping the company manage uncertainty in shifting consumer preferences.
The Role of Personal Competencies in Managing Uncertainty
Managing uncertainty requires the development of specific personal competencies. According to researchers, effectively navigating uncertainty involves:
- Adopting a growth mindset that views challenges as opportunities for learning and development.
- Developing analytical and decision-making skills for ambiguous conditions.
- Fostering agility and innovation to adapt to uncertainty.
- Enhancing strong communication and collaboration skills.
- Encouraging continuous learning.
Interestingly, research shows that **”the ability to manage the emotional discomfort of uncertainty is key to making sound decisions.”** Furthermore, studies have found that **”people perceived leaders as more competent when they expressed uncertainty about a decision.”** Leaders were rated more favorably when they opted to gather more information rather than immediately selecting a strategy. This aligns with the concept that in uncertain situations, “choosing not to choose” and gathering additional data is often perceived as a reasonable approach.
Decision-Making Frameworks for Different Levels of Uncertainty
Researchers and business practitioners differentiate between three key conditions in decision-making: certainty, risk, and uncertainty.
– **Decision-making under pure uncertainty (“I don’t know”)** occurs when decision-makers have no knowledge about potential outcomes, even in terms of probability. Behavior is purely based on their attitude toward the unknown.
– **Decision-making under risk (“I know probability estimates”)** occurs when some knowledge is available, allowing decision-makers to assign subjective probabilities to different outcomes.
– **Decision-making through gathering more information (“I can obtain reliable data”)** involves acquiring additional knowledge to reach a level of reasonable certainty.
The causes of uncertainty include lack of information, information overload, conflicting data, measurement errors, and subjective interpretations of available facts.
The Future of Decision-Making Under Uncertainty
As suggested by **NBER research**, the traditional approach to uncertainty relies on the “riskification fallacy,” where decision-makers believe that unpredictable events can be accurately captured by probability distributions. This is problematic because the consequences of uncertainty shocks go beyond what a typical manager can predict, involving complex internal and external factors.
The future of decision-making under uncertainty will likely rely on more sophisticated approaches that integrate insights from multiple disciplines. Bayesian statistical theory formalizes the idea that optimal inference and learning critically depend on representing and processing different types of uncertainty in behavioral contexts.
According to Gartner researchers, **”effective decision-making, redesigned to be connected, contextual, and continuous, accounts for uncertainty and improves our ability to bring clarity to previously opaque considerations. This becomes a competitive differentiator.”** In an uncertain world, organizations that can **”handle greater uncertainty than others, comfortably and skillfully, will have the ultimate advantage.”**
Conclusion
Decision-making under uncertainty is one of the greatest challenges faced by modern organizations and their leaders. Scientific research and business practices provide valuable insights into navigating these uncertain waters. The key is understanding different types of uncertainty, developing the right personal and organizational competencies, and applying appropriate decision-making frameworks for different levels of uncertainty.
As research shows, the ability to manage uncertainty can become a key competitive differentiator in today’s fast-changing business landscape. Organizations that learn effectively and adapt to uncertain conditions will be better positioned to seize opportunities and mitigate risks in the future.
Empatyzer – The Ideal Solution for This Challenge
Pillar 1: AI Chat as an Intelligent 24/7 Coach
The AI chat understands the user’s personality, character traits, preferences, and organizational context. It delivers highly personalized advice tailored to both the individual and their team. Recommendations are provided in real time, helping managers solve problems immediately rather than waiting for training sessions.
Pillar 2: Micro-Lessons Tailored to the User
Twice a week, users receive short, condensed micro-lessons via email that can be absorbed in just three minutes. These lessons are personalized—focused either on the manager (e.g., their strengths, weaknesses, and how to utilize them) or on team communication and relationships. Practical guidance includes real-world scenarios, actionable techniques, and even suggested phrasing for specific situations.
Pillar 3: Professional Personality and Cultural Preference Diagnosis
The tool analyzes the user’s personality, strengths, weaknesses, and unique traits in the context of their team, company, and the broader population. This allows individuals to understand their position within the organization, identify talents, and determine the best operational style.
Empatyzer – Easy Implementation and Instant Results
– **Rapid Deployment** – No integrations required; can be implemented in companies with 100–300 employees in under an hour.
– **Zero Additional HR Workload** – Users don’t generate additional questions or work for HR, significantly saving time.
– **Immediate Business Value** – Designed to be quick, easy to implement, instantly effective, and cost-efficient.
Why Is Empatyzer Unique?
It understands not only the individual asking questions but also their organizational environment—providing solutions tailored to real-world challenges. A comprehensive tool that combines coaching, education, and analysis into one, available with no effort required from the user.
Discover more about training for managers.
Looking for online communication training? Visit our main page.
